IC 2714: “The Rip-Torn Cluster”

Introduction:

Humanity was introduced to the Rip-Torn Cluster when it was first observed in 1826 by astronomer James Dunlop. It is called the Rip-Torn Cluster because of its torn-up appearance(O’Meara, 2013) and is more commonly known as IC 2714. The Cluster is located within the constellation Carina at Right Ascension: 11h17m29.5s and Declination: -62°43′08″. Due to its location in the southern hemisphere, IC 2714 is never visible from Saskatoon.

 

Observation:

Using the Prompt-5 telescope from the Skynet Robotic Telescope Network, I remotely collected five images of IC 2714 with each of the filters B, V, and R, for a total of 15 exposures. The exposure length of the images was approximately 65 seconds for the B filter, 35 seconds for the V filter, and 20 seconds for the R filter. I then used Afterglow to align and stack the 5 images of each filter, I used the stacked images to extract sources for photometry and later to create a color image of IC 2714.

IC 2714 in Color

Once the sources were extracted I used Afterglow to perform batch photometry on the three stacked images, I then uploaded the results to the Cluster Pro Plus software to create an HR diagram and isochrone model of the stars within IC 2714. In Cluster Pro Plus I first isolated IC 2714 in proper motion and distance, which gave me a proper motion estimate of -7.76 milliarcseconds per year(mas/year) of RA and 2.6 mas/year of DEC. Then I loaded the Gaia data for the cluster and plotted HR diagrams of M_RP vs BP-RP and M_H vs J-H.

Results:

Using Cluster Pro Plus I altered the parameters of the cluster until the isochrone model fit the data on both diagrams to get estimates for log(Age), reddening E(B-V), and metallicity. Doing so yielded a distance of 3 kiloparsecs, a log(Age) of 7.95, a reddening value of 0.61 magnitudes, and a metallicity of 0.7 solar metallicities. I also made a second set of HR diagrams using parameters from the Milky Way Star Clusters Catalog(MWSC), which gave me a distance estimate of 1.224 kiloparsecs, a log(Age) of 8.65, a reddening value of 0.416 magnitudes, and a metallicity of 0.01 solar metallicities. I used the estimated E(B-V) values to create de-reddened images of IC 2714 which are shown below along with the HR diagrams for both my parameters and the MWSC parameters.

 

De-reddened image of IC 2614 using my estimate of E(B-V) = 0.61
De-reddened image of IC 2714 using MWSC value of E(B-V) = 0.416
HR diagram using my estimates as parameters
HR diagram using the MWSC values as parameters

 

A paper by Clariá et al (1994) investigated IC 2714 and found that it contains eleven red giant stars and one variable star. The paper also provided a distance of 1.32 kiloparsecs, a log(Age) of 8.5, a reddening value of 0.36 magnitudes, and a metallicity of -0.13 solar metallicities. I plotted the given values with Cluster Pro Plus and created a de-reddened image just as I did with the previous two parameter sets. Upon comparing the three sets of HR diagrams I believe that my estimates of the parameters are inaccurate since both the Clariá et al and the MWSC HR diagrams have isochrone models that fit the data better. I believe that the main issue with my parameters was that I estimated IC 2714 to be much further away than it actually is, which caused the data to be shifted higher on the graph than it should be.

HR diagram using the Clariá et al values as parameters
De-reddened image of IC 2714 using Clariá et al value of E(B-V) = 0.36

 

Blue Stragglers:

The HR diagrams for both my estimates and the MWSC values showed the existence of a few blue stragglers within IC 2714, which I have confirmed through further research. A 2011 study found that the blue straggler stars in IC 2714 became blue stragglers after leaving the main sequence but before helium ignition (Lu Pin et al 2011).

 

Conclusion:

Overall, I really enjoyed the opportunity to research IC 2714 and learn about star clusters in the process. IC 2714 is also really cool to look at, and I am grateful that I had the chance to create such nice-looking color images.